Monday, November 21, 2011

Harry Potter vs. Twilight

a facebook discussion between my friend N and me:

N: Well if i have to vote, i'll vote for Twilight,. :). Nytime a 19 yr old vampire is way too better than a 11 yr kid wizard :)))) :P

Me: 
  • first of all that 19yr old vampire is not so 19 yr old :P
  • second, harry potter doesn't remain an 11yr old kid all his life, he learns, he grows, unlike ur 19yr old vampire.
  • third, harry potter is more than a sickly sweet vampire love story where characters are cut outs of popular culture and never achieve anything in life.
  • fourth, harry potter is a celebration of friendship, of victory of good over evil, of respect for elders, of living against every conceivable odd... can twilight series ever match it :)

so what do you say? who would you chose between the two?

-adee


btw, you can check the actual winner here on Mashable, from whose shared link this post and subsequent discussion originated: http://mashable.com/2011/11/18/twilight-breaking-dawn-harry-potter/


4 comments:

Prats said...

Harry Potter Any Day!!

Kanupriya said...

what? what?! there's no question of 'vs' here. HP is way, way ahead!

Adee said...

thanks Prats and Kanu :) though the ratio here is completely skewed towards HP fans, it became the most hotly debated topic on my facebook page till date :D thanks for the comments

opinionsandexpressions said...

Harry Potter rules!! A girl involved in a love triangle with a vampire and a werewolf??? what crap!

dreamt before

Related Posts Widget for Blogs by LinkWithin